Without a doubt more about A Girl Like we
A audience writes
I understand you’ve got written with this issue prior to, but We begin to see the problem has arisen even yet in your message that is latest. You state вЂњFor those of you who, anything like me, hadnвЂ™t been aware of SI symbols, youвЂ™ll locate a list right here.вЂќ
вЂњLike me personally. вЂќ My husband and I also have already been arguing within the use of вЂњme and/or IвЂќ daily. I might state вЂњlike me personally,вЂќ and he claims, вЂњlike I.вЂќ We have actually a sinking feeling he could be grammatically proper. Response please?
If only all grammar concerns had been as simple to respond to since this 1.
It is never ever, ever proper to express вЂњlike I.вЂќ
In Gentlemen want Blondes, Marilyn Monroe plays a blond bimbo (just what else?) certainly one of her conversational character tags is вЂњlike I?вЂќ When arrived on the scene in 1953, the viewers ended up being anticipated to laugh whenever she stated it.
вЂњLikeвЂќ is really a preposition. Prepositions ALWAYS simply take an object. The object form of вЂњIвЂќ is вЂњme.вЂќ
IвЂ™m sorry to discover that also someone thinks that вЂњlike IвЂќ is really a grammatical possibility in standard English.
The wrong utilization of вЂњIвЂќ in compound things after the preposition вЂњtoвЂќ has been in existence for quite a while now. For instance: they certainly were extremely nice to Michelle and I also.
Placing anotherвЂ™s title at the pronoun will not change the fact that вЂњtoвЂќ is really a preposition a form that is object these were really friendly to Michelle and me personally.
that this use that is incorrect of after like does not result in the strides in popular message that it has after transitive verbs.
Like to improve your English in five full minutes each day? Obtain a membership getting our writing recommendations and workouts daily!
Keep learning! see the Grammar category, always check our popular articles, or pick a associated post below:
- Program vs. Programme
- “Wracking” or “Racking” your mind?
- 7 Other Styles of Pronouns
Stop making those mistakes that are embarrassing! Today Subscribe to Daily Writing Tips!
- You may boost your English in just 5 minutes per guaranteed day!
- Subscribers access our archives with 800+ interactive exercises!
- You can also get three bonus ebooks totally free!
Take To It Totally Free Now
34 reactions to вЂњA Girl Like IвЂќ
- Gwen on 13, 2009 3:57 am july
вЂњLike IвЂќ can too be utilized properly. As an example, that horrible track with similarly bad sentence structure should state вЂњDonвЂ™t you wish your gf had been hot like we,вЂќ since the finished verb expression could be вЂњвЂ¦like i’m.вЂќ
Dan on July 13, 2009 5:04 am
The majority of the above article had been extremely enlightening, IвЂ™ve been enjoying these blog sites. The one thing i did sonвЂ™t never understand: вЂњItвЂ™s, ever proper to say вЂњlike IвЂќ. What exactly is grammatically incorrect about вЂњFor those of you whom donвЂ™t care like i really doвЂ¦вЂќ or comparable?
Daran on July 13, 2009 6:42 am
вЂњLikeвЂќ is really a preposition.
Love can also be more successful as being a combination. вЂњLike IвЂќ is thus defensible on the causes it is the main topic of a phrase whoever predicate is elided.
No body can dancing like he (does).
It appears horribly unidiomatic, however, in the event that verb is elided.
Brad K. on July 13, 2009 12:27 pm
Daran, oh, this is certainly evil. So you contend an implied вЂњdoвЂќ or вЂњcanвЂќ following the вЂњlike IвЂќ. *shudder*
Oh, that . . . no. You may rest content, yet we will . . in my situation and the house, http://privatelinesdating.com. uh, utilize вЂњmeвЂќ where appropriate from what is obviously *there*.
Michael Batey on July 13, 2009 2:01 pm
IвЂ™m uncertain it is вЂdefensibleвЂ™, Daran, nonetheless it can get a way to describing exactly how this arises after вЂlikeвЂ™ вЂ“ the vague feeling that a verb must certanly be coming along at some time makes the item convulse into an interest.
The wider issue of вЂвЂ¦and IвЂ™ is right down to hypercorrection: schoolchildren have had it drummed into them for such a long time that вЂJonny and IвЂ™ went along to the store, maybe not вЂJonny and meвЂ™, that вЂDad took Jonny and us to your storeвЂ™ sounds somehow incorrect towards the unenlightened. For people of us who wince every right time they hear this use, everday discussion are something of an effort.
Vic on July 13, 2009 2:28 pm
thought that with all the expressed wordвЂњlikeвЂќ there clearly was a suggested ending. Obviously, if you say вЂњa woman like we,вЂќ the phrase вЂњamвЂќ is implied. Then it would seem that вЂњmeвЂќ would be the correct word if itвЂ™s not implied. Imagine if we substituted the terms вЂњsimilar toвЂќ for вЂњlikeвЂќ? Then вЂњa woman comparable to me personally.вЂќ Or would it not? This indicates rational considering that the term вЂњtoвЂќ produces a item as opposed to an interest. In вЂњa woman like We,вЂќ which can be , and which can be ? It looks like вЂњgirlвЂќ is the item, therefore wouldnвЂ™t this make вЂњmeвЂќ the rational option as the item?
Chad on July 13, 2009 2:46 pm
Being an ESL instructor, I run into this example whenever we arrive at comparatives. Sentences with вЂњlikeвЂќ are just like sentences with вЂњthanвЂќ and I also often explain that can be used the pronoun that is subect in the event that auxiliary verbs and modals are clearly included. Which means it is possible to state вЂњShe is taller than meвЂќ or вЂњShe is taller than we amвЂќ but вЂњShe is taller than IвЂќ is embarrassing and may be prevented. Within the instance provided when you look at the post, there are not any auxiliaries or modals following the pronoun that is demostrative,вЂќ making вЂњlike IвЂќ an impossibility.
Sally on July 13, 2009 2:46 pm
I had been thinking We comprehended this presssing problem, nevertheless now i am aware We donвЂ™t.
Although IвЂ™m a writer that is professional it comes a family members gift as opposed to my capability to comprehend the intricacies of this language. nвЂ™t determine the elements of message in a phrase even when somebody dangled a sum that is large of right in front of me personally.
That said, i usually believed that by the addition of another вЂobviousвЂ™ word that may come in the phrase, i really could вЂtestвЂ™ whether the best word had been вЂmeвЂ™ orвЂ™ IвЂ™.
Therefore for me personally, the test when it comes to sentence when you look at the readerвЂ™s question will be to include the phrase вЂamвЂ™, making the expression вЂlike we (am)вЂ™, because you wouldnвЂ™t say вЂlike me amвЂ™. My вЂtestвЂ™ for the other instance is always to eradicate вЂњMichelleвЂ™ through the phrase rendering it вЂThey had been extremely friendly to MEвЂ™ (because I wouldnвЂ™t say вЂThey had been very type to IвЂ™).
Really, now about it, I believe I may have learned that in school (U.S.) many years ago that I think. HmmвЂ¦..